Punchy or Walker?

[Born2BWild]

I have a dilemma. When I first started my game, Punchy was my resident lazy villager, and I grew to like him. When one of my villagers moved, the "replacement" villager I got in return was Walker, who I originally didn't want to keep around long. However, the little guy has grown on me (he's cute, plus his house is in a really good spot), and I'm thinking about possibly keeping him in my town. But since I only want one lazy villager, I'm now torn between them.

So what do you guys think? Should I keep Punchy, or go with Walker?

 

[Leebles]

I think Walker is cuter, especially because of the music that plays in his house. I also have a soft spot for Lazy dogs - they just seem like they fit the lazy mold better. Plus Punchy makes for good trading, so you have a higher chance of getting someone else you want.

 

[Selky]

I'm biased. At first I never had Punchy as a dreamie...I thought he was cute but I left it at that.
Early this year my black and white cat passed away (he was a FeLV positive cat and they don't live
very long). After that I really wanted Punchy so I could still sort of see a black and white kitty everyday.
Since getting Punchy...I truly love his goofy facial expressions. Specifically this one.

 

[Lurrdoc]

Even I can't decide.

 

[Hybridbreeder1]

WALKER WALKER WALKER WALKER

.....

but if you chose not to keep him I will take him off yours hands hehehe ;3

 

[Waluigi]

Both are really cute, and punchy is quite awesome, but walker looks better and has a better house imo (plus 2 days ago as his song=instant twiggy seal of approval)

 

[cIementine]

Walker. Punchy gets annoying after a while. Walker is an awesome dude, and if Beau or Joey were to ever move out on me, he's my guy!

 

[jokimori]

lazies are great imo! keep them both hehe....(but if i had to choose... i love walker!)

 

[Improv]

I prefer Walker more; Punchy looks like he found a bag of dope on the side of the road. :3

 

[Bear_Crossing]

Punchy. I'm biased because he lives in my town, but he's adorable.

 

[Aromatisse]

Cats > dogs, so Punchy.

 

[JaeJae]

I have them both before and Punchy is awesome

 

[cheezu]

I'm biased. At first I never had Punchy as a dreamie...I thought he was cute but I left it at that.
Early this year my black and white cat passed away (he was a FeLV positive cat and they don't live
very long). After that I really wanted Punchy so I could still sort of see a black and white kitty everyday.
Since getting Punchy...I truly love his goofy facial expressions. Specifically this one.
View attachment 30388

Aww... Sorry to hear about your kitty, melsi.
I love tuxedo cats. They're precious.

I'm also biased because I'm a crazy cat lady so I'd always go with a cat villager. Plus I really like Punchy.

 

[Zeiro]

I like Punchy better. I had Walker and he's boring.

 

[Gizmodo]

I love both Dogs & Cats
but Punchy is much cuter imo

 

[Born2BWild]

Seems the populace is divided right down the middle with this decision. Maybe I'll just end up keeping them both...

 

[PinkWater]

Walker's way cuter, imo. I just love his beady lil eyes~

 

[~Yami~]

Punchy <3
I remeber when he was in my town, everyone wanted to give him a blow torch for his bithday >~<
I pefer cats and plus I think punchy is adorable <3