POLL: Who Do You Think Is The Unknown Sender Of The Letter?!

[toenuki]

I want to know who thinks sent the note because in my other thread there were tons of options.

So, this is to make things seem exciting as a debate will take place!

Comment below if you wish to say something or add your vote to see who will get the most win in the heat of this battle!

So, who do you think it is?

 

[snapdragon]

I voted Tortimer but who is NL Villager Racer?

 

[elle7]

I voted Tortimer but who is NL Villager Racer?

I think it means the character from Mario Kart, the one who looks like one of the male player characters.

 

[PandaBerryInSpace]

I think it was Rover... Though, I've seen people argue that it was Isabelle, and I can kinda see it.

 

[elle7]

Can't there be a "none of the above" choice? Because I don't think it could really be any of them. Maybe the Villager Racer at a push?

 

[Mariah]

None of them. Isabelle is clearly the secretary, Tortimer retired by his own choice, and the villager from Mario Kart has nothing to do with the lore of New Leaf. The only plausible one on your list would be Rover, but I really doubt it.

 

[toenuki]

I can't edit I don't think but it's out of them sorry they were the most popular choices in my other thread so I put them.

 

[Seth Lios]

I'd vote 'none of the above' as well, for the reasons Mariah stated. I just don't see any of those characters as the intended mayor.

 

[meenz]

I voted Tortimer because he used to be the mayor and it makes the most sense (to me)!

 

[NightDelight]

I didn't vote for any since I don't think any of them would want to be mayor. Maybe Digby could? Idk

 

[DarkFox7]

Rover. I just have a feeling it's him.

 

[smalltowncrossing]

Rover. He was on the train with us and was very questioning of us the whole time, possibly questioning if we would be a good candidate for the mayor position he was supposed to uphold. The problem with this theory is that Rover and the player character will not share a name most likely and Isabelle will know your name when you arrive in town hall for registration so the Villager character is also a very possible answer as they can share the same name with you.

 

[PlasmaPower]

I think it could be one of my starter villagers.

 

[DarkOnyx]

None.

Isabelle's a secretary, she's supposed to be commited and responsible. No way she'd back out of a mayor position so late, and throw it on to the next random person who moves in.

Rover doesn't even know of the town until you tell him. He also would have missed his stop. You could say:he lied. Why would he lie? It makes no sense.

Tortimer is the old mayor. If you read the letter carefully, you'll know for a fact it wasn't him.

ACNL V Racer has nothing to do with this.


Personally, I think it's someone completely different who we haven't met yet, or may never meet who missed their train.

 

[lunathenia]

The only theory that makes sense is Rover but it's not logically sound either.
Idk the MK8 character so can't say anything about that.

 

[toadsworthy]

Think though, who could be so charming and likable to the point of being hired without Isabelle even knowing their name? Who else is able to find out so much perceptively and through interrogation about you and you not even question them about anything? Rover! I believe when you state your destination, doesn't Rover use the surprised emoticon? Like he's shocked you said it? thinking quick on his feet he pretends to not know it... but he DOES know it, I mean he then gives you ONLY 4 options of maps knowing you are gonna pick the right one! Still trying to play it off...

Isabelle doesn't make sense- she was the past secretary... there wouldn't be 3 villagers and a train ceremony if she was to be the intended mayor

Tortimer doesn't make sense- he has this whole island gig pretty planned out and seems happy with new found retirement. everyone knows he was the last mayor, why go through all the rumors of a new mayor if its just gonna be him?

MK 8 villager is a little trickier until you use common sense- the MK 8 villager is packaged with Isabelle... so they must know each other. The whole process of becoming kart racers is not something you do with a stranger and she clearly doesn't know the mayor who DIDN'T come on the train because she mistakes you for the new mayor... I think the villager is intended to be your mayor, showing all the free time he has when not doing mayor duties (well clearly if you aren't playing New Leaf and playing MK8, your villager could be anywhere, including kart racing).

 

[elle7]

Maybe it's the first villager who moves in after your starter 5. They're the next to appear in town after you.

 

[toadsworthy]

he doesn't use surprised emoticon on the train, but my other reasoning stands

- - - Post Merge - - -

Maybe it's the first villager who moves in after your starter 5. They're the next to appear in town after you.

but sometimes those villagers are like, I heard about Mayor *you* and heard this was a really cool place... so that can't be it

 

[elle7]

he doesn't use surprised emoticon on the train, but my other reasoning stands

- - - Post Merge - - -



but sometimes those villagers are like, I heard about Mayor *you* and heard this was a really cool place... so that can't be it

Yeah but that's all part of the "keep it a secret" thing

They load the position of Mayor on you, and then waltz in and act like they know nothing.

 

[Leela]

Rover doesn't even know of the town until you tell him. He also would have missed his stop. You could say:he lied. Why would he lie? It makes no sense.

I always thought that if it really was Rover, he could have just been making sure you were headed to the same town as him when he asked you to show him the location on the map. But I agree with you that it probably wasn't Rover, and also smalltowncrossing in that it doesn't explain how Isabelle knew the mayor's name as soon as they got off the train