I love both of these jock kitties and they both live in my island. While both of them are Jocks, they have different sub-personalities. Kid Cat is more of about fitness, while Rudy is more about playing.
I'm not asking who I should kick out. I just wanna know which one do you like better.
I think they're both adorable but I have to go with Rudy because I've had him in one of my NL towns since 2015 and he's my friend's favorite! I love how his name is Rudy and he has a round red nose and brown/white fur, like Rudoph the red-nosed reindeer except as a cat.
I have no idea if he was actually meant to be, especially since his Japanese name is something else I think? But he just really reminds me of Rudolph lol and I think it's super cute.
I'm biased since I've never had Kid Cat as a villager before but Rudy was in my WW town and I loved bothering him as a kid so I definitely like Rudy more.
I had both on NL and went through phases of one of the two being up there with my favourite villagers. Rudy is definitely my pick out of the two. Something about his design is really charming yet simple but I don't think you can go wrong either way.