Pick a snooty for my island

[MindlessPatch]

I can't decide on a snooty for my island and Vivian is asking to move out. She's the last villager to move out (i.e. all 9 others I'm 99.9% sure I'm keeping) so whoever I get will never ask to leave which makes me nervous therefore please help me decide.
Here's who I am considering: Annalise, Blaire, Blanche, Bree, Cleo, Mint, Pecan, Willow, Yuka

If you like having more information...
No real theme to my island but it is more nature focused - lots of trees, dirt paths.
Other villagers are: Mitzi, Agnes, Dotty, Chief, Rolf, Zell, Shep, Sherb, Mott.
Also I'm putting a photo I put together of all the contenders interiors and exteriors aha

Spoiler: house photos

I appreciate all opinions ^^

 

[FaerieRose]

I'd go with Blaire. Her house is themed around flowers, and you don't have a squirrel-type villager.

 

[Pintuition]

I really like Mint, I have her on my island! I find it so hard because of the inability to change the way the house exteriors look! I have villagers I love on my island but their houses really clash. I think Mint probably would clash a bit with the natural theme. If that's important to you, I'd go with Annalise. Her interior and exterior is super cool!

 

[TheSillyPuppy]

I'm biased towards Mint -- I loved having her on my island. I put a pear tree with white, blue, and green flowers in her yard. Her house might stick out with the natural theme, so I'd suggest Blaire or Pecan as alternative choices.

 

[Roxxy]

Naturally slightly biased suggestion but had you considered Whitney ? Always been my fav villager

 

[Bk1234]

My original pick was Mint, but after looking at the interiors my pick is Blaire. Since you’re going for a nature-themed island, Blaire’s interior that has pokes of flowers everywhere is just a nice touch. It shows that she incorporates nature into her everyday life.

 

[MindlessPatch]

Oh I hadn't actually thought about how bright Mint's exterior is. Sherb's exterior is quite similar a bit more of a pastel colour however and I love how his little area turned out so maybe Mint would be okay. I'll definitely keep that in mind when deciding thank you both for pointing it out!

Post automatically merged: Aug 6, 2020

Naturally slightly biased suggestion but had you considered Whitney ? Always been my fav villager

I'm only doing one villager per species (like no double ups) and already have Chief who is my absolute favourite hence Vivian leaving if not I would have absolutely considered Whitney she's lovely!

 

[*The Oakboro Mayor*]

I was originally going to go with Mint, but I read about your town being kind of rustic/forest vibes and decided I would pick Blaire!! She is super cute and has a very nice plain-but-rustic house that I think you be a nice addition to your town. Mint does a have a house similar to Sherb though, so if you don’t mind his house so much I think Mint would be a nice addition too! Good luck choosing your villager, I’m sure you will get a good villager no matter who you pick.

 

[dizzy bone]

From your list I would pick Blanche. She’s a great snoot and her exterior would suit your theme and easily fit in natural areas. I’ve had Blanche before In New Leaf and she was one of my favourite snooties. Really pretty and elegant! If you were ever planning an area to use bamboo in your forest, Blanche’s house could be the perfect spot for that too!

 

[dino]

i have blanche rn and really do love her house and her sweet design she blushes a lot ! super cute.

but ! i voted for annalise for you because her design is very natural and would match your island real well! she seems really sweet and unique - the island theme is fun and you could design around that. her character design is also compelling but aligns with the other villagers you already have & you dont have a horsie on the island yet

good luck picking someone !

 

[MindlessPatch]

Thanks so much to everyone that's voted and replied so far! It's really interesting and helpful hearing other's thoughts behind which villager they voted for. I told Vivian yes and will be time travelling sometime tomorrow to speed up her move out by one day because I'm working the day she would naturally depart and won't have the time to go villager hunting so gotta do it tomorrow instead. I'm off to bed for tonight and using this to bump the thread before I go as it's just about to go to next page.

 

[Lavamaize]

I would pick Willow. She's one of my all time favorite villagers, and her interior is really nice. It has a very clean and classical feel to it.

 

[Larsi]

I had Mint and she is cute. Also has a calm house to look at. Really liked her, but not a favorite so I let her go

 

[kayleee]

I have Blaire in my New Leaf town and I love her! And the outside of her house looks like it would really fit your nature theme.

 

[Chris]

The last villager to move in can ask to leave! So don't feel like whoever moves in will have to be a permanent villager.

Based on your description of your town I would say Pecan or Mint. Pecan because she's very natural looking and Mint because her colour scheme compliments natural colours.

 

[loveclove]

I know you didn't consider her as an option but I have to say, Diana is the perfect snooty. The personality suits her very well, and her design is gorgeous

 

[Sweetley]

I would personally go for Willow, she's in general a great (snooty) villager and I think her house (both indoor and outdoor) would fit to your island theme. Alternative, Pecan is also a good choice.

 

[spawnpoint]

Willow is my favorite one on the list. I'd go with her ^^

 

[Millysaurusrexjr]

Definitely either Pecan or Mint

 

[tajikey]

Poll is invalid without Tasha.