Pekoe or Kiki! Help!

[BluebearL]

Hi everyone! I should open with I have at least 1 of each personality and only 1 normal atm so that’s not a factor. Additionally I do not theme my villagers so I just want to hear which one you guys think is best! I love them both sm but only have 1 open plot! Lmk!


And please tell me why! Convince me that only you are right. Srsly help

 

[Halloqueen]

I find Pekoe to be adorable and am planning to adopt her onto my New Horizons island, so I'm throwing all of my support behind her. As someone who doesn't put stock into the villager tier lists, I'm surprised to see that she's only in the C tier. She has a great, unique design and it appears that she could do with more attention and love. I like Kiki for her black cat design and the Kiki's Delivery Service reference, and I enjoy some of the cats, but I feel like they're a bit overdone.

Give Pekoe a chance!

 

[BluebearL]

I find Pekoe to be adorable and am planning to adopt her onto my New Horizons island, so I'm throwing all of my support behind her. As someone who doesn't put stock into the villager tier lists, I'm surprised to see that she's only in the C tier. She has a great, unique design and it appears that she could do with more attention and love. I like Kiki for her black cat design and the Kiki's Delivery Service reference, and I enjoy some of the cats, but I feel like they're a bit overdone.

Give Pekoe a chance!

Tysm! Just adopted pekoe now as I saw this response lol. She is very cute so I am happy with my choice. I’m not particularly interested in the tier list either. Many of my favs are underrated and I have more fun discovering the adorable underrated ones I didn’t notice before so I’m happy to have adopted pekoe.

 

[Fye]

They're both so cute. I'd go with Kiki cause black cats don't get enough love and cause the Kiki's delivery service reference is so sweet. Plus I feel like she would look great in any clothes

 

[niko@kamogawa]

I love Pekoe! (She's one of my dream villagers that I adopted in this forum.)

She's not getting much attention indeed. But I like her design simply because of eastern feel!

 

[maaango]

I would go with Kiki! Was always a very big fan of Studio Ghibli so she reminds me a lot of it <3

 

[Clock]

I prefer Kiki because I like cat villagers and she is a bit underrated and cute.

 

[Magus]

I really love Kiki so maybe I'm biased... I love her so much I now consider having two Normals on my island even if I wasn't fond of this personality in the beginning, but I surely want Coco and can't see myself get rid of Kiki.

I know I'm too late but Kiki ! Her huge yellow cute eyes that contrast with her black fur is a success in terms of simple and efficient design + she almost looks like a bat lol