Peanut VS Cookie?

[Rabirin]

I'm thinking of switching out Cookie for Peanut, the only trouble is it took me quite a while to obtain Cookie. Who do you think is better Peanut or Cookie?

 

[Blueskyy]

I got Cookie from campsite. I currently have Peanut. Peanut has always been my favorite. I prefer her much more.

 

[wolfie1]

I think Cookie is cuter, but Peanut is cute too.

 

[Rabirin]

I got Cookie from campsite. I currently have Peanut. Peanut has always been my favorite. I prefer her much more.

I'm kinda leaning towards that way as well, but I feel like if I get rid of Cookie I might regret it and want her back.

 

[Blueskyy]

I'm kinda leaning towards that way as well, but I feel like if I get rid of Cookie I might regret it and want her back.

You never know until you try. I moved Carmen out just to get Peanut back, and I loved Carmen. Then again I like squirrels.

 

[AppleBitterCrumble]

I prefer Cookie more, her home is very cute and so is her personality (You can even see it shows on my forum post about her adorable convo with Marshal). Also who doesn't love a pink dog that looks super cute asf

 

[MintySky]

I like Cookie more because she is cute and her house is really pretty. But then its your choice so choose whichever one you think you like best.

 

[Belle of Pripyat]

I prefer Peanut. Cookie's face looks jacked up to me.

 

[survivorfan111100]

Cookie is cuter to me and since it took you a hard time to get her, I would keep her.

 

[AccfSally]

Peanut, I don't like Cookie.

 

[Tikikata]

I had Peanut. She's a sweetheart. <3

 

[santoyo.bay]

I have had both, and prefer Cookie. I have her now and absolutely adore her

 

[Rabirin]

Thanks everyone for the input, although I think i'm going to go with Peanut. I spammed Cookie's interactions quite a bit and i'm just not feeling her tbh. Also I had Peanut in wild world, so I guess she's a villager i'm more familiar with rather than Cookie.

 

[Vickie]

♥ I prefer Cookie, because she is in my town right now,
so I might be biased...
But I like pink and cute, so Cookie definitely fits the bill c: ♥
~♚Vickie​

 

[MillySoSilly]

Peanut. I, personally wasn't a fan of Cookie to begin with.

 

[Fenix]

I prefer Cookie, but Peanut is cute too.

 

[toadsworthy]

Cookie and all the dogs really are just meh... Peanut was the first villager I met in ACNL and she is pretty cute

 

[Trip]

I've never had either but I like Peanut's design better.

 

[Chicha]

I'll agree with Peanut! Her exterior and interiors of her house look adorable imo.

 

[Blueskyy]

I'll agree with Peanut! Her exterior and interiors of her house look adorable imo.

Her interior is very homey with that nice kitchen set up