Newl Leaf. Unerrated? Overated? Middle of the Rode?

[Mekan1]

What do you think new leaf is, very overrated, underrated, middle? I think personally that it is underrated and should have more popularity than it does currently

 

[-Apples-]

It's more middle road to me.

 

[Koala_Tea_]

middle

 

[FireNinja1]

In the middle, I guess. The game's reviews, looking back, I mean after awhile it just gets boring, but at the same time, you've already squeezed so much out of the game in the first place.

 

[Laudine]

Middle I think. Definitely not underrated, but at the same time not ridiculously overhyped

 

[n64king]

Totally middle. There's no way it's under or over rated, it's a great game, reviews and the community reflect that. I've yet to see anyone poopoo it or give it more praise than it's deserved.

 

[Hipster]

Middle for sure.

 

[RayOfHope]

Definitely middle, the game isn't hugely popular but the general opinion of those who have played it is very positive (particularly that of long-time AC fans).

 

[LambdaDelta]

middling

overrated seems a stretch, since from what I remember NL was a lot of people's first game in the franchise (at least here), and I really don't think I've seem many people give less credit than its arguably worth

 

[Melody]

Middle, like most. I feel like this game can go in many directions.

*if that makes sense

 

[Chibi.Hoshi]

Middle of the road. It's not underated nor overrated, it's just in the right spot.

 

[Ankhes]

I think its ranking is in the proper spot.

 

[Mango]

over

iidk i just cant stand it sometimes, i like old versions so much better

 

[spCrossing]

It kinda lost it's attention a year ago with Pokemon X & Y.

It's more or less middle in the road, fantastic gameplay, decent villager mechanics, and a meh soundtrack.

 

[alwatkins]

I like it a lot. I am kinda sad that it is hard for me to find others who play it where I am.

 

[Ami Mercury]

I find it underrated. Close to being as underrated as Frozen.

 

[Mango]

I find it underrated. Close to being as underrated as Frozen.

thats a joke right

 

[Kirby of the Stars]

My favorite in the series was the Gamecube version for many reasons. Once Wild World rolled around, I found that to be highly overrated because they took out so many of the things I came to love (the train station, the police station, the dump, the Island, etc.). The same sort of happened with City Folk. I didn't play CF nearly as much as the two before but even with more additions, graphics, and villagers, it didn't feel the same to me. But that all changed when New Leaf rolled around. They brought back so many of the things I loved and added so much more onto everything. Sure, the dialogue is very shallow and becomes repetitious very quickly, but I do still love it. Not to mention that I always wished you could be the mayor.

All in all, I think that it is middle ground as well. Even though the Gamecube version is the most lacking of content, it is certainly the strongest in charm. New Leaf finds a happy-medium between control and charm. It really does feel like your town in all the right ways.

 

[Eline]

I voted middle of the road, allthough I do think there are a lot of people who are very negative about the game (when you're older than 12 and you play, you know. people think it's stupid) but I can imagine that not everyone likes the game. I think the game gets the recognition it deserves.

- - - Post Merge - - -

I find it underrated. Close to being as underrated as Frozen.

Frozen is not underrated? I'd almost say Frozen is overrated. (Allthough I do love the movie, don't get me wrong)

 

[jakeypride]

Totally Middle!