I've got Marshal for trade, and he should be original excluding his shirt. I really really hope to get Kiki for him for sure, but i will take other villager offers. Kiki is an automatic yes and preferable.
Sadly I am also after Kiki, so I cannot help you there. What would you ask for in terms of tbt? It's been awhile since I've looked into Marshall prices, hahah.
Oh, too bad! Good luck with the trade. Marshall is worth a bit more than Kiki just so you know. Make sure you get a good deal. There is a list by popularity that has suggested prices as well if you would like to take a look at your dreamies.