Jock villagers [Help me decide!]

[Princeles]

Hey!
I'm trying to find a new jock villager but I'm undecid, so I was hoping someone would help me to decide
I already have Dom on my island and I love it, but he doesn't fit at all and he's the one I least talk to, so I'm considering on get rid of him..
Anyways, I want at least one jock villager on my island, so there are the options!

Bam: i love his design and i don't have a deer villager yet, so it's a pro
Genji: i would love to have him on my island but i already have a rabbit, and if i had it i would like to have pekoe too, because i like that ship
Rudy: already have a cat and his house exterior is kinda meh.. but he's so cute though!
Pierce: idk about this one.. i'm not fascinated at all but i've never had a eagle villager, and his design is pretty cool!

I'm a very indecisive person, so that's why i'm doing this post-- please help me out and give me some tips or opinions!

 

[Jam86]

bam is so groovy, my sister has him and he's so cute ♡
however genji is also adorable so if it were me, i'd pick one of those two ☆

 

[Tehya Faye]

Genji probably has the best house interior of the bunch (Rudy's is also nice), but I personally really like Pierce's design as a villager. Such a pretty blue.

 

[MatchaMoonlight]

I had Pierce in New Leaf, and while I liked my other jock at the time (Hamlet) better, I still really liked Pierce. I like that he has a more athletic build, lol. I think he really suits the jock personality. I'd personally go with him.

 

[greenvoldemort]

Genji is adorable! and yes.. genji and pekoe?? best ship to set sail ever! i know this isnt on your list, but another bunny jock i would consider is snake! he’s a ninja.. bunny.. enough said! LOL!

also dont worry about having one too many of the same animal type, and thats coming from someone with 3 cubs on my island..

 

[Madrox6]

I have Pierce now, and I really like him! He has a nice design and really fits the jock personality. His interior is really sporty as well

 

[Piggleton]

Bam is super cute but the house is left to be desired... genji has one of the cutest house exteriors and interiors! I would pick Genji slightly over Bam just due to the house but can’t go wrong with either!

I actually just got bam myself and so far he’s been such a cutie! I still think I’d prefer genji and imagine I will replace bam with him one day.

 

[Le Ham]

Seems like, based on how you feel about each one, your best bet would be Bam or Genji. Both are cute, solid picks - I think the jock personality suits Bam's appearance well! And Genji x Pekoe would be fun if you wanted to do that!

Personally, I've allowed myself to take in a second hamster in Rodney after already having Clay, and I've changed my mind about having all unique species - they feel different enough that I don't mind at all! I think Genji and Bunnie look quite different and wouldn't feel like more of the same, but that's up to you

 

[FyreNyx]

My friend has Bam and he seems cool!

 

[lolli8223]

Out of these two Rudy or Pierce. I don’t think Rudy really fits the jock personality well though. His house looks like a little kids room with a train set in the middle. I plan on giving him workout gear to help haha

I love Pierce, dunno what his house looks like but I’ve had him in past games and really enjoyed him.

 

[Fendi]

From the four you listed, I would probably rank them in this manner - where Bam is the top choice.

Bam > Genji > Pierce > Rudy

I think all of them are pretty good choices, but I'm a little biased since I love deer. I've never had any of them on my island, but I have seen others who have Bam and he is really nice! Genji is cool too, along with Pierce. I think Rudy is just OK to me, though I do know there are plenty of others who love him, I think the other three are better choices though, in my opinion.

 

[Tehya Faye]

Out of these two Rudy or Pierce. I don’t think Rudy really fits the jock personality well though. His house looks like a little kids room with a train set in the middle. I plan on giving him workout gear to help haha

I love Pierce, dunno what his house looks like but I’ve had him in past games and really enjoyed him.

You can see Pierce's interior down this page. It's nice and sporty! Unfortunately Pierce is my starting Jock so I'm gonna have to move him out someday. Hopefully I'll be able to get him back, or get Genji/Snake to fill that spot.

 

[ayeeprill]

Bam out of those options! I also personally love the frog jocks especially Ribbot and Frobert!

 

[lolli8223]

You can see Pierce's interior down this page. It's nice and sporty! Unfortunately Pierce is my starting Jock so I'm gonna have to move him out someday. Hopefully I'll be able to get him back, or get Genji/Snake to fill that spot.

I love it! It’s MUCH better than Rudy’s house

 

[Alicia]

My boyfriend has Bam on his island, Bams really cute.
I've got plans to have Rudy on my island in the future, hes cute and his house looks cute too.

 

[Reploid]

Fierce Pierce!

 

[Damniel]

pierce or bam! had both!

 

[Princeles]

Omg! Thanks for all the answers!! Tbh I'm still undecided because the different opinions of everyone hahaha but i think that's great~~
Some of you are recommending other jock villagers that are great too, but I think these are my top 4 overall- and I still have enough time to decide until Dom asks me about leaving

 

[Hobowire]

i like genji but may i suggest hamlet?

 

[InstantNoodles]

Pierce is cool but what about Sterling?