Help Me Decide...Ètoile or Phoebe for Fairytail Themed Town

[AquaMarie]

So I am making a town that is divided into different "fairytail" type sections and I'm wondering which of those two you think will fit best.

In my "Mythical Forest" area I have Julian, Drago, and was originally going to go with Phoebe since she looks like a phoenix. But I'm thinking ?toile looks very cute and also very fairytale themed, even though she isn't a specific type of mythical creature. I think she would look nice living next to Julian...unicorns, clouds, rainbows, stars, etc.

In my Gingerbread Forest section I have Merengue, Tia, and Zucker. And then an Egyptian section with Ankha and Lucky.

Either way, ?toile is a must have for me so if she doesn't work out here, she'll have to go in my other town.


EDIT

On the off chance you haven't seen ?toile, here she is

 

[Panda Hero]

?toile. totally.

 

[nintendoanna]

eh ?toile just doesn't look that good to me but she would definitely fit in a fairy tale town

 

[Vickie]

♥ ?toile is really cute!
and her pastel color would totally fit in a fairy tale themed town c: ♥
~♚Vickie​

 

[Nodokana]

?toile

 

[GreenLeaf]

Etoile is adorable and absolutely great for a generic fantasy and dreamy theme but I think that Phoebe fits better with your villagers

 

[mayortiffany]

Phoebe would fit in better with your theme of mythical animals but ?toile is very cute and definitely fits into a fairytale aesthetic. I think it depends on what you'd like: a town with all mythical animals or just fairytale animals.

 

[ashlif]

?toile is cute. I'd go for her with the theme having a fairy tail theme. But Phoebe is good for the mythical forest section if you want her.

 

[sizzi]

etoile is my baby in Rainfall and i love her! i have had phoebe but etoile definitely goes best with your theme and is just better all around ^^

 

[uwuzumakii]

?toile is the obvious choice here. She just screams "fairy tale" to me.