
The problem is, I told Jeremiah he could move. He's not in boxes though, so I can still save him.
Glad you went with Jeremiah! I like to see the less popular villagers getting some love.
I had a similar experience with my second town. I had my villagers all planned out, told Zell he could move, and then noticed that, to my surprise, I was actually sad about it. Then I realized how dumb it was for me to give up a villager I'd grown to like naturally just for some original concept of what the town "should" be, and I convinced him to stay.