Are Villager Christmas Wishes The Same?

[SaturnTown]

I tried to look and see if a similar thread had been started, but I didn't see one.

I was wondering if villagers will ask for the same thing no matter what, or if it's random. Here's my list of what everyone wants:

Flora: something green, furniture
Julian: umbrella, something aqua
Mint: carpet, something yellow
Daisy: something green, musical instrument
Bluebear: something yellow, wallpaper
Lucky: something brown, carpet
Zucker: blue, household appliance
Puddles: clothing, something black
Pango: umbrella, something yellow
Monty: furniture, something black

 

[Saranghae]

Nope, they're always random.

 

[SaturnTown]

Ahh, okay! Thank you!

 

[PikaSweet]

no there the same my Whitney and my friends Whitney asked for the same thing...

 

[poliwag0]

no there the same my Whitney and my friends Whitney asked for the same thing...

What was it? I can check with my own Whitney.

 

[FireNinja1]

no there the same my Whitney and my friends Whitney asked for the same thing...

That's just an extreme coincidence. It's random.

 

[nammie]

no they're random... i.e. I have zucker too, and he asked for a beige carpet, not a blue household appliance like OP's zucker

 

[MetaTriforce]

I have Zucker and Julian, who both asked for different things than what yours asked for. Zucker wants gray wallpaper and Julian wants blue clothing (even though he's wearing blue clothes right now).

 

[PikaSweet]

That's just an extreme coincidence. It's random.

oh ok.......

 

[VioletsTown]

I think its random. I had a good list going when i tt'd into the future to restore grass/snow, and when i came back to "real" time, everyone told me something diffenent they wanted

 

[Squeaky]

It's definitely random. I had written all of my villager's wanted gifts down, and then accidentally TTed past Toy Day and they all changed. Lol.

 

[Swiftstream]

its random.
My julian wants brown clothing!

 

[Dembonez19]

My Flora wants a red instrument! Definitely random.

 

[kerryelizabeth]

My Julian wants a green plant. Totally random :3 Although my Lucky does want the same thing as yours

 

[RisingSun]

I'm agreeing with everyone else that it is random. My Pango wants a green carpet. Any likenesses are totally coincidental.

 

[priceiswong]

This might be a dumb question, but I'm new here (and to Animal Crossing). Do WE supply those items? I've heard requests from my townspeople too..

 

[VioletsTown]

This might be a dumb question, but I'm new here (and to Animal Crossing). Do WE supply those items? I've heard requests from my townspeople too..

No. Apparently Jingle gives you a bag with all the toys and you distribute. You do need the full jingle outfit, though. I read up on it on thonky!

 

[priceiswong]

No. Apparently Jingle gives you a bag with all the toys and you distribute. You do need the full jingle outfit, though. I read up on it on thonky!

Ahh that makes more sense! Thanks!
Now I need to get the full jingle outfit! I'm running out of time!

 

[Mao]

Gawd my villagers keep changing their mind. Erik wanted furniture. Then something blue. Now a plant omg jfksjlfd

 

[yourlilemogirl]

[nvm ;0]