Another Which Should I Get Thread

[MightyMunchlax]

I know there have been a million of these and everyone is probably sick of them, but I can't decide. I'm making a second town in August and I already know 9 of the dreamies that I definitely want, but I can't decide on the last slot. The dreamies I have decided on for sure are: Lolly, Rudy, Chrissy, Francine, Marshal, Poppy, Goldie, Phoebe, and Hugh. I primarily am doing pairs, but the last few obviously aren't. Having personality balance doesn't particularly bother me. So don't pick one just to add balance cause I don't care. The ones I'm considering for the last slot are: Curt, Stitches, Twiggy, Puddles, Peggy, Diana and Timbra. Give me some opinions. I'm still debating what to do with this town. I'm thinking of doing a high society type city where everyone is really wealthy, just with less snobby looking villagers (though I think it would be cool to do a real one and have a bunch of snooty and smug "high class" looking animals, but I really just want another town for dreamies). If you have any suggestions for what else to do with the town I'd be willing to take those as well. Keep in mind the 9 villagers I've chosen are pretty much set in stone. The only one I'd consider swapping is Phoebe and I'd probably switch her out for Mira if I did, but then I'd have 3 rabbits so I'm probably not going to. I'm just rambling now. Please vote.

 

[Leopardfire]

Puddles is really awesome. <3 Her house is kinda strange though, its like a backyard.

 

[MightyMunchlax]

I think she's cute but a lot of people don't like her. I love peppies though. :3 I have 3 in my main town.

 

[scribblezoeya]

I've never actually heard of most of these, but my friend used to have Stitches and said she's awesome. I guess you can take her word for it xD

 

[Bcat]

My personal favorite is Stitches. But Puddles and Diana are cute also.

 

[Ettienne]

I like Diana's design, but Stitches, while creepy, is also cute in his own way.

 

[Trickilicky]

I voted for Puddles! She lives in my Pond-theme town and she's so cute, how anyone couldn't love a pink frog is beyond me ;-). If I had a second vote it would go to Twiggy, I love her canary bird design and her impressive eyebrows ^_^

 

[Hound00med]

Curt, Puddles and Stitches are the best out of the list.. They're all fantastic villagers and are definitely underrated (but not Stitchface of course)

 

[Fuzzbyroo]

I would say Peggy (one of the pigs that I actually like lol). I used to have her in my previous town c:

 

[Crazy-Gamer]

 

[Zane]

I saw Twiggy and voted her immediately, but after reading the op I don't really know who would be the best fit for your town. I'd still go with Twiggy though.

 

[MightyMunchlax]

View attachment 56060

That's adorable! :O I do like Stitches a lot, but I like any of them. Which is why I asked for other opinions I'm so indecisive. XD And I didn't just include some because they were underrated my dreamie list is actually very long and all of these are on it. I could easily fill this town and another with different villagers. It's so hard narrowing it down! ><