Alright my turn... Rank 'em for me?

[Lovi]

We've got Dobie, Kitty, Audie, Midge, Lyman, Zucker, Raymond, Wolfgang, Erik, and Sherb
(This in order of the picture in my description ;D)

I have my personal reservations as to me- they're all s+ but... I'd love to know how others feel about them, so, rank away!​

 

[ayeeprill]

10. Raymond
9. Zucker
8. Wolfgang
7. Lyman
6. Kitty
5. Midge
4. Sherb
3. Dobie
2. Erik
1. Audie


I really love all of them besides Raymond and Zucker so this was hard T-T

 

[petaI]

1. audie
2. wolfgang
3. raymond
4. midge
5. kitty
6. zucker
7. sherb
8. dobie
9. erik
10. lyman

 

[Tasuot]

1. Audie
2. Erik
3. Raymond
4. Zucker
5. Sherb
6. Dobie
7. Wolfgang
8. Midge
9. Kitty
10. Lyman

 

[Rosewater]

10. Raymond
9. Erik
8. Zucker
7. Lyman
6. Midge
5. Sherb
4. Dobie
3. Kitty
2. Wolfgang
1. Audie

 

[lieryl]

10. midge
9. kitty
8. erik
7. zucker
6. lyman
5. audie
4.dobie
3. raymond
2. sherb
1. wolfgang

ill always have a soft spot for wolfgang T^T

 

[Arithmophobia17]

alrighty, i'll try my hand. it'll be pretty obvious which of these are my dreamies lol
1 - raymond. not only a personal favorite of mine but he came to my island rather recently so he's still feeling rather new.
2 - sherb. he's my bday buddy and super sweet, what's not to love?
3 - dobie. old man wolf. nothing else to say
gets kinda tricky here since the rest aren't dreamies of mine lol
4 - audie. cool design plus the grandma lore is pretty awesome
5 - zucker. he was my starting lazy and it was nice to have him around and i honestly kinda miss him, but he went to a good home and made someone else happier than he made me, so all's good.
6 - wolfgang. i really like the wolf designs, and his coloring is pretty cool. not one of my favorite wolves but i wouldn't mind having him on my island
7 - Erik. i don't really care for him but he seems rather sweet, his design just doesn't really stand out to me.
8 - mmm prolly kitty. i really like cats but to me her design is on the lower end of them, not bad but again doesn't stand out to me
9 - lyman. cute enough but he's just not up there for me, plus he's a jock and jock's aren't really my fave
10 - midge. just really not my cup of tea, i'm sure she's sweet but i don't really care for many of the birds and i don't love the pink/white coloration personally

they all seem really nice though, i love that every villager is someone's dreamie despite how popular they may be or not

 

[Lethalia]

10. Zucker
9. Raymond
8. Sherb
7. Dobie
6. Erik
5. Audie
4. Lyman
3. Midge
2. Wolfgang
1. Kitty