All of redds art being fake?

[Insulaire]

Early on and today I had all fakes. A villager sent me a real statue in the mail.
My other island has had real piece each time Redd visits.

I've never had a villager send me art in the mail! Do you get them sending them big gifts? I always just send wrapped foreign fruit, just like in the daily gifts.

 

[FraudulentDimetrodon]

I've never had a villager send me art in the mail! Do you get them sending them big gifts? I always just send wrapped foreign fruit, just like in the daily gifts.

For me, it was just a random letter out of the blue. The letter was unique and mentioned that the gift was art, so actually, I'm not sure if they can even give art as a response to gifts or not. Either way, it's a pretty rare occurance. I've only had one and I've played since March.

 

[Insulaire]

For me, it was just a random letter out of the blue. The letter was unique and mentioned that the gift was art, so actually, I'm not sure if they can even give art as a response to gifts or not. Either way, it's a pretty rare occurance. I've only had one and I've played since March.

Oh, that's good to know! I only rarely remember and go through the effort of sending gifts via the mail since they don't effect friendship according to the datamine, so I was worried I might be missing some opportunities. I guess I'll just have to wait for sweet lady RNG to show me her favor!

 

[stitchmaker]

I've never had a villager send me art in the mail! Do you get them sending them big gifts? I always just send wrapped foreign fruit, just like in the daily gifts.

No big gift. The first time I got a statue from a Cranky after buying fake painting the day before. It was a real Robust Statue. Cranky mentions it something he had collecting dust. It was the first time I bought artwork from Redd and I went with what I knew from ACNL. Amazing is different in this game. I have 2 island and have received 3 fake statute and one fake painting. All were from Cranky villagers.

 

[CodyMKW]

If your really lucky sometimes all four pieces of art can be real

 

[Sharksheep]

If your really lucky sometimes all four pieces of art can be real

I don't think that's even possible. You have 10% of 3 being real

 

[Insulaire]

They did say you'd have to be REALLY lucky!