All of redds art being fake?

[matt2019]

Is it normal for redd to sometimes come and all his art is fake? Because this just happened to me

 

[Chris]

Yes, it happens unfortunately. Happened to me the very first time he came to my island.

 

[Bethboj]

Yup, unfortunately this is a thing. Last time I saw Redd he had all fakes, at least I wanted the toaster he had

 

[matt2019]

Yes, it happens unfortunately. Happened to me the very first time he came to my island.

Thanks. Yeah it’s either they’re all fake it seems or his real art is ones I already have. Not sure how I’m supposed to complete my collection that way

 

[Chris]

Yup, unfortunately this is a thing. Last time I saw Redd he had all fakes, at least I wanted the toaster he had

One can never have too many toasters.

Seriously, I break them with alarming regularity.

 

[matt2019]

Thanks for the replies

 

[Ossiran]

According to dataminers, you have a 10% chance of him having all fakes, and a 10% chance of him having 3 real pieces.

 

[Hoshi]

Sadly it happens, on the bright side I had him visit with more than one genuine piece before.

 

[Pintuition]

I didn't know he could bring all fakes! I did see a post once that claimed Redd brought someone real paintings and a real statue. I've never been so lucky! Haha!

 

[Hobowire]

yea I am okay with the fakes.

 

[Cherry Tree]

I bought something today for the first time off the boat...I have no idea if it's a fake yet but I love it anyway even if it is

 

[yosie1511]

According to dataminers, you have a 10% chance of him having all fakes, and a 10% chance of him having 3 real pieces.

So there isn't a possibility to get all 4 genuine?

 

[Alicia]

I've had all fakes before, but I was also able to get 3 real pieces once.
That was nice considering the time before he only had fake art!

 

[Skyfall]

Yes. This can happen. It has happen several times in a row for me which was so bad. It’s all RNG unfortunately

 

[Fraggle]

This happened to me and whilst I don’t TT, this was the one occasion I went forward one day and reloaded straight back to change the offer on the boat and it did work!

 

[Reploid]

According to dataminers, you have a 10% chance of him having all fakes, and a 10% chance of him having 3 real pieces.

Wow, I must have some bad luck because he's shown up a few times with all fakes.

 

[Xeleron]

I don't think it has happened to me yet, I did get 2 real pieces once, one was a statue and the other one a painting.

 

[Ossiran]

So there isn't a possibility to get all 4 genuine?

No there is not. You can never have 4 real pieces unless they changed it with the recent update.

 

[Insulaire]

If you're ever faced with all fakes again and there's nothing you want, you should buy a fake statue over a painting if there are any available, since they are worth more on the resell/trading market here.

 

[stitchmaker]

Early on and today I had all fakes. A villager sent me a real statue in the mail.
My other island has had real piece each time Redd visits.