I know that people have tier lists for villagers, but I want personal opinions as well. Here's my island's resident history (Some moved away) I'll also be mentioning how I got them
Shari the Uchi Monkey: Starter
Antonio the Jock Anteater: Starter
Puddles the Peppy Frog (Moved): Random move-in...
I bought my Sherb for 200 NMT, so it is plausible. After all, he doesn't have an amiibo
1592499337
Especially if ungifted, he could go for a lot, just my two cents🤷♀️