AmazonEvan19
Wait
Have I been wrong in dismissing VaNessA? Dismissing Nightmares v Ness as scum v town while TRing Ness is honestly, honestly, just so pointless to point out.
Also, really don't like Evan's singling out of Punchy here, when all three of that trio were equally at fault and literally no logic was brought up against him at that point. (Evan, if you're going to challenge this, you better provide quotes besides that thing that I later retracted. And voting for people who aren't in the game has never been a valid reason to sus someone)
Eh
Actually like this, shows good thinking and reading between the lines which I like.
Overall I'm mixed on Evan, he's def lower than Chele though, right now I have the following as possible teams of the four
Teams
Chele/Evan
Chele/Vanessa
Evan/Vanessa
Moving onto Vanessa and stopping there
What's interesting about this is that he uses an attack strategy on two known relatively new players on stuff that's rather weak and should honestly not be considered. Chele for her playstyle selection, and Evan for alarm at copying me. I find this reachy and ultimately scummy.
Wait
Wait
Have I been wrong in dismissing VaNessA? Dismissing Nightmares v Ness as scum v town while TRing Ness is honestly, honestly, just so pointless to point out.
Also, really don't like Evan's singling out of Punchy here, when all three of that trio were equally at fault and literally no logic was brought up against him at that point. (Evan, if you're going to challenge this, you better provide quotes besides that thing that I later retracted. And voting for people who aren't in the game has never been a valid reason to sus someone)
Alright, straight off the bat my first reaction is to say that VaNessA would be the most likely of the other three to be Evan's teammates if he's scum, then Chele, then Nightmares. Evan really has a problem TRing people he shouldn't
Mehno? I admittedly skimmed the thread somewhat quickly so if you wanna show me something of yours that's a scumslip, by all means
I'm kinda uncomfortable with Evan not recognizing this as a townslip but ultimately don't think that it contributes any way towards determining his alignment
See above honestlyoh lol, that's my mistake then, I've said sounding for a while but no one's corrected me on it
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh
yeah I remember reading that post. Hmm...Punchy WAS the first one to name drop "citizen," right?
in which case, that'd be a pretty damn big point in his favor...unless the scum rolepms say "you win when you equal the citizens" or something
This just sounds bad. He completely misses the obvious conclusion that this would have to be pre-meditated for Punchy to come out like this. Also, another 180 on if Evan townslipped in the space of 15 minutes. He's literally changed his opinion twice already.
This actually seems like good content and makes me what to TR him, and is his one good post so far going into this.
Same here, he's cognizant of a lack of teammates for Dedenne, and although he does ultimately vote for her, it does read well for him I feel.The one thing I'm good at as scum is trying to post town like analysis posts, to be sure.
Punchy's behavior has been pretty scummy so far, but the whole citizen bit has me somewhat questioning my read of him. I still don't think it can be used as a definitive metric to read him though, since we obviously don't know what the scum rolepms say, or if the scum have town safeclaims. Doubtful in a game this size, but still. On its face, the Punchy situation is making me think he's scum, but he also acted annoyingly scummy last game as well and was town.
I scumleaned Dedenne because as you said, she's not really been producing quality content so far. What stood out to me was the vast majority of her posts are ****posts, and the ones that aren't barely qualify as analysis posts. The problem is, as of now I don't see anyone as a real ally of hers in the thread rn. I only see people calling her out for ****posting.
Meh
Meh
Evan really has to stop scumreading noobs for poor play. Gonna say possible teammates are Ness and Chele right now. At this point I'm suffering from a lack of motivation so just follow along.Townleans
Ness ? sassy, assertive, pissed off ? typical town ness. I have a hard time believing that the more calculative scum ness would be able to pull off organic reactions like his.
Zendel ? giving off very townie vibes for me. His self-deprecation and posting style that Chele pointed out align with his town meta.
Chele ? impressive analytical work, though could easily be done as either alignment. But I really think Chele has town?s best interests at heart and I don?t see her teaming with anyone I find scummy.
Seroja ? I like her reads and tend to give bonus points to people who don?t just insta suck up to me.
Null
Nightmares ? their meta is apparently to post poorly reasoned, ad homenim attack-filled posts as town, and she?s following that playbook to a T this game so far.
Toads ? I?m liking his questioning people. He?s also getting kind of triggered, which is another town trait of his. He did, however, defend dedenne, which I am a bit uneasy about, so I?m null reading him for now.
Punchy ? the now-outted ???TP???, who has no mention of town/citizens in their rolepm, thinks punchy is probably town because of the citizen bit. I can kind of see it, and punchy is acting very much like he was last game, but I am still leery of him. Null for now.
Scumleans
Dedenne ? ****poster extraordinaire, plus difference of tone between this game and last, has me pretty convinced she?s scum. Let?s hope the lynch is correct
Bianca ? she isn?t acting dumb, she isn?t acting all panicky town, she?s acting like a weird hybrid of crazy and just ignoring everyone. A very plausible teammate for Dedenne, since she seems like she?s hiding from the thread
TP
Dolby ? my gut instinct is to believe survivor claims. 8v2v1 is very plausible and eliminates the possibility of Bianca being fool, cuz no way in hell this is 7v2v2 with a fool/jester role too. Dolby has prior history of claiming TP under duress though sooo he?s still a potential lynch candidate, but for now I think we need to get Dedenne or Bianca, preferably Dedenne. Dolby could be using the citizen confusion to hide behind the fact that he's really scum with no mention of citizen in his rolepm, and thus using Punchy's citizen outting to his advantage so he can obfuscate his own identity.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Has cleb hosted before? If so, has he typically included TPs? I'mma investigate this
- - - Post Merge - - -
just ctrl-F'd xcleb on all 16 pages and didn't find another game he's hosted. Well rip that idea
- - - Post Merge - - -
nightmares should be under townleans btw
Meh
Feels fake manI'll pm you the explanation lmao, I may get banned if I put it publicly here
Also xcleb, I think that flavor was way better than the Dragon Ball flavor, not gonna lie
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh and rip dedenne
@Toads: Idk, the fact you want me to change you to a townlean cuz of the flip is kinda sus. Like you knew dedenne would be town and are now looking for us to give you town points?
Kneejerk reaction. Kinda mixed on this. On one hand it seems emotional, but also seems like preemptive defense and discouraging me from trying
Eh
Eh, nothing here.
Bianca actually posts something decently substantive that makes me think Toads *could* be right on this one. Occam's Razor dictates that...
- Punchy is town because of citizen
- Dolby is survivor because why tf would he claim that as scum
- Bianca is town because of the misspelled word.
So despite all of Bianca's less than forthright behavior, it may be useful to assume she's town on an operational basis. Tbh I probably picked a bad person to ISO since Bianca's posts usually don't yield much info and are often contradictory or poorly reasoned, which she does as either alignment.
It may, however, be useful for me to go through Seroja's posts, since a lot of sus is being thrown her way, and I want to derive a stronger opinion on Seroja myself.
- - - Post Merge - - -
oh SensaiGallade is in now, ohai
give us three good reasons Seroja wasn't scum or else lyncherino train
Actually like this, shows good thinking and reading between the lines which I like.
Overall I'm mixed on Evan, he's def lower than Chele though, right now I have the following as possible teams of the four
Teams
Chele/Evan
Chele/Vanessa
Evan/Vanessa
Moving onto Vanessa and stopping there
