I literally can't narrow it down because I love so many of them, I voted for Lolly, Kid Cat, Bob, Tangy, Kiki and Ankha.
Lolly I love her "real cat" colors and she's just absolutely adorable. Her little "3" mouth and everything about her is precious.
Kid Cat, one of my favorite "costumed" villagers, I love his little helmet and the fact that he has "pants" on. Plus his colors are really nice.
Bob, he's a purple cat, what else can you ask for? Oh yeah, the #1 best catchphrase ever! Only complaint I have is that he should be Smug, with those eye, it would suit him soooo well!
Tangy. SHE. IS. AN. ORANGE. I love all of the food villagers, they're just too amazing, honestly there needs to be more fruits and veggies so her and Ketchup can have more friends.
Kiki, gotta love her cause she's a BLACK CAT! What witch doesn't love black cats? She's the perfect combo of creepy and cute.
Ankha, who doesn't like her, she's a darn goddess! I do wish there was more "egyptian" esc villagers and some way to get a sandy town because that would be such an amazing theme! We already have the PWP's for it, so I mean, give us a desert option!