Walt (still in my town since launch), Timbra (same as Walt) Carmen, Bud and Biskit.
I had them all in my town for a long time. Let go of Bud because I wanted Snake as my jock, Carmen because she started to be less friendly for some reason and Biskit because I had Stitches and Prince who added variety plus I wanted another orange villager (Tabby)
Didnt like them at first because they were all neutral colors and it felt like my town lacked variety :v