I used to like Bam a lot but he reminds me too much of somebody I know inrl and now I can't just shake the thought off. I think he's cute regardless and his freckles are a bonus. (i'm a sucker for anything with freckes) Fauna is pretty cute never really took to her as most people did, but I think she's an alright villager, I see the appeal. Her colour scheme also helps a lot if you're going for a forest theme or any theme really. I find that neutral villagers go with almost any theme. Also, she's the closest looking deer to one in real life so I think that's why i'm leaning towards her more than Bam.