Mac, he's kinda ugly. Never see him in any towns either, so that'd probably be a unique addition. He's kind of like a villager you forget exists in game, until he moves in. Barold, there's a ton of hate threads about him so you probably already know how ugly he is. He's a lazy. I'd also suggest Graham, he's not really ugly just looks like a really creepy guy, and the fact he's smug makes it worse. Beardo's ugly in my eyes too, but these are all just my opinion.