• Happy Earth Week! TBT is hosting a series of nature-based mini-events through April 28th. Breed flower hybrids by organizing your collectible lineup, enter our nature photography contest, purchase historically dated scenery collectibles, and earn bells around the site! Read more in the Earth Week and photography contest threads.

Your personal tier list?

My current villagers: Toppest of top tier
Everyone else: Lowest of low tier
 
Tier 1 - Carmen

Tier 2 - All of my other villagers in both of my towns, plus villagers I have amiibo cards/figures for

Tier 3 - everyone else (except the ones I dislike/hate)

Tier 4 - every villager I dislike/hate (I don't have cards for them)

Tier 5 - MARSHAL. (Fight me, I hate him the most.)
 
off the top of my head
Tier 1: Clyde, Pashmina, Poppy, Beau, Maddie
Tier 2: Tipper, Freya, Curt, Vladimir, Stinky, Iggly, Scoot
Tier 5: Marshal, Hopper, Bill.
 
Top Tier: Sally, all squirrels, All rabbits, All my villagers in my four towns.

Bottom tier: everyone else
 
Top tier: Villagers I like
Middle tier: Villagers I've never had/got attached to
Bottom tier: villagers I dislike (Elise, Pompom, Hippeux, Chops)
 
just a list of the villagers i have or i've recently had.
tier 1: tammy (want!), coco, ruby, tangy, kiki, marcel, chief, katt, kyle, felicity
2: flurry, pashmina, skye
3: diana
4: marshal
5: -
 
T1: Julian, Lolly, Skye, Melba, Merengue, Maddie, Cookie, Dobie, Fang, Beau, Punchy, Phoebe, Genji, Leonardo, Bunnie, Pecan, Kitty, Vivian, Sylvana.. probably a few more. I love a lot of the Normal personality villagers

T2 - T4: there's too many to name. I don't care for Marshal or Stitches very much, they'd probably be T3 for me.

T5: every mouse villager (especially Greta), Hazel, Katt, Pietro.. probably a lot more
 
Tier 1- Tabby, Katt, Bella, Marshal
Tier 2- Pretty much almost everyone else
Tier 5- Julian and Ed
 
Last edited:
Tier One: Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches, Stitches

Tier Six: All else.
 
Tier 1 all my villagers Diana, Fauna, Chrissy, Fuchsia, Nana, Marina, Flora, Peanut & Cookie (not in order as I love them all the same) and a few of my other favorites that don't match my towns theme Stitches & Portia

Tier 4 overrated villagers that I dislike .. Merengue, Marshal, Francine, Bluebear, Margie, Lily

Tier 5 villagers I absolutely hate .. Penelope, Snake, Bob, Cobb, Julian, Rasher (pretty much any pig, horse, frog, -- actually there is a lot more can't even name them all but this is a pretty well organized list)
 
All the really ugly bottom tiers are tier 1 for me. Except Hippeaux. But the other cute ones like Hazel, Beardo, Jambette, Wart Jr., are all tier 1 now.
 
My personal tier list is that all my villagers are on the same level (Tier one) as every other villager. This doesn't mean that I disagree with the tier list, because it's a good way of pricing villagers but I just like to think that all animals are equal in the game, because they're all villagers at the end of the day. Even villagers I don't like, LOL.
 
Back
Top