1. Dark Feather
because it was very very challenging to earn and its the most rare modern collectible.
2. When i first joined TBT, i had no interest in collectibles, except for one that caught my eye, that I was hoping to one day possess, because it is the Kingliest of all collectibles (and my good friend gave me one during the Fair)
White Feather
3. Spring Shamrock
because it was the first Spring seasonal collectible to be issued, and because it came out on St. Patrick's Day, making it the first collectible issued on a minor holiday (they previously only issued for the major holidays). Seems like this one paved the way for all of the new varieties of collectibles that came after...
4. Popsicle
cause it was all the craze back in the day bc of Team Popsicle,
and right when it's price was crazy highest my generous friend gave me one
5. the retired Easter eggs
Wah!
6. BellTree Fair Patch
aha I had wanted one for a long time, so glad there was finally a Fair last year
7. Christmas Candy Cane
the perfect collectible for Christmas
8. Wierd Doll
for one magical day everybody had one!
9. Pokeball
i was very very lucky to find one, altho it makes me sad they weren't restocked for the new members to honor Sun/Moon.
10. Classic cake:
i spent all my new member tbt buying these for my ACNL friends when the collectibles bug first hit me lol
11. ?
mine disappeared. RIP you will be forever missed my precious ?
Finally, there's one super cool ultra-rare collectible I never had the chance to snag, sadly: