A while ago, I created a thread that that asks who you favorite AC dog is. Now that the update has occurred, I'd like to see how it has impacted the votes. You can vote up to 3.
My favorite dog villagers are Lucky, Marcel, and Butch.
Lucky is my overall favorite because of his mummy-inspired design. He fits into my town well alongside Ankha and they add a nice ancient Egyptian feel to things.
Marcel is my second favorite because I like the clown/mime villagers. I wish they brought back Pierre the cat with the amiibo update because he'd fit in well with Pietro and Marcel.
Butch is an iffy third-place pick because he has some competition from Shep. I favored Butch in this because I have had him show up in my towns in the GameCube game, City Folk, and New Leaf. I like his Cranky personality and his design isn't half bad, so he's good in my book.
Honorable mention goes to Shep since I had him at one point and I think he's a pretty great villager with a nice design. Portia would probably be my favorite as far as the female dog villagers are concerned, but none of them have as good and striking designs as the three I chose already.
I only voted for Goldie and Bones but I forgot Cookie and Butch, lol. I just wanted to see if Goldie was there because she's my favorite villager and I got carried away.