I might as well roleclaim now to avoid another mislynch. I am
Sapphire the Detective and I have inspected
Cadberry and
Qwerty111 both of whom returned town. If I die tonight, I hope that this will prevent you from lynching Qwerty because we need them to win.
As of tonight 8 players remained, 2 of which are mafia. Assuming that Shiida is a third party, we have only 5 town players left with three confirmed towns. See below.
Seroja - Confirmed town, detective.
Cadberry- Confirmed town, veteran? Inspected N1
Qwerty111- Confirmed town. Inspected N2
Cass123- Definite town. I have town locked Cass from Day 1 and I absolutely can't see her as anything but.
mogyay- Town lean. I have considered her answers to my questions very carefully and I believe that she is town. It was however quite disconcerting when she accused me of killing both Miharu and tui simply based on my reads on them, but I think this is a natural town thing to do (if not, this could be something to look into). She is also very consistent with her reads.
Rosetti- Scum-read. I do believe that you were clueless when you made those reads. Just not as clueless town, but rather, clueless mafia. You overused the clueless excuse. For every single scummy thing that you did, it was because you were clueless/new. There are links on the opening post for mafia guides. I find it hard to believe that you're 100% clueless about this game. Also on the fact that you did not know what sheeping is despite it being a hot topic on D1. Plus you said you PMed someone asking about it hmmm, who was it?
The last point was something that I picked up from your interaction with Lucanosa.
Lucanosa- Scum-read. Going on my gut feelings alone, I have always felt uneasy with your posts; every single one of it. They just sound, a bit, too calculative. Like you were trying real hard to be helpful to us NOOB townies and were shoving this fact down our throats every chance you get, right from your first ever post to your latest one. I have always felt like you were hiding behind the pretense of wanting to HELP us noobs with how the game works so that you can get away with not contributing much on anything else. And for the longest time, I bought it.
Your posts were mostly on wanting to catch up on posts, 'give advice to newbies', and promising to write reads. And when you did give reads, your reads were mostly the same as other players' with absolutely nothing new added in. You scum leaned Moonbrink and Qwerty who everyone else were already sus of. Then you were suddenly sus of Shiida, Mog and Rosetti after Qwerty and I made posts about them. And yet you were blaming the NOOBS for bandwagoning. How ironic.
I call any townie lynch a ****lynch lol it's just my word for a mislynch.
tbqh, I never really suspected Sparro of being scum, and more like scared/busy town, and when he flipped blue, it confirmed it. what's bothering me now though is how someone (person A) brings up someone else (person B) as possibly sus and then everyone bandwagons and because most of the players here are new, the reads are all over the place (which is to be expected), and the bandwagons are literally running us all over.
What does this make you then hmm? A ****ty Mafia. That's what.
And to the part that I am most suspicious of:
Rosetti - scumlean - shady af, you've posted massive posts all in response to people attacking you, and it makes me wonder why you're so desperate to protect yourself
like.... esphas's death was different (the esphas effect is what I'll call it I guess), but even tho they seemed scummy, moon and sparro's deaths were via bandwagon. someone posted their suspicions because of a few sketchy posts and no one tried to argue about how they are or aren't what the claims said they were. and the only person who really fought for their safety from fear of lynching was rosetti.
I'm starting to suspect if some of the people who I've thought were town are actually scum....
while I'm working on my reads/cases I'll also be going over everyone's posts along with the meta of the few players on here who aren't newbies.
1. You thought Rosetti defending herself as
shady af for 'desperately' defending herself.
2. You claimed Rosetti was the only one who put up a fight to protect herself from being a mislynch victim(at least that's how I read that sentence)
Okay Luca. What were Mog and I doing all these while then? Did we look like we were hanging out having fun talking to each other? Did you not see the 'walls of text' between me and Mog defending ourselves from each other's suspicions? Hmm. You kept saying how you're 'going' to read everyone's posts but now I'm starting to think you didn't even bother because you didn't need to. You already know who everyone is.
Did you bus Rosetti because she's looking scummy to a lot of people then? So that if she got lynched and she flipped scum people won't think about looking at you? But when you see that she didn't get lynched you tried to salvage her image?
Also it seems to me that you were preparing to shift your scum reads to me and mog. You're already planning to make a case for mog anyway, which I beat you to btw.
timing is key with mafia
you say something at the wrong time and your head will be on the chopping block.
Tell me then Luca, if you knew this, why did you ask who I think the 2 scums are in the dead of the night (
#676)? Did you purposely want to get me killed? Or were you looking for a reason to kill me? This is very telling Luca. You did not care for my safety at all, I am somewhat hurt by this.
also I said before I don't have all day to come on and read, post, etc.
like, I have a lot of things I need to finish by the end of the summer for college so I can't waste all of my time questioning and pushing people, especially when it's giving little in terms of results seeing how quiet the thread is.
I guess I was on silent mode then? I made so many posts on the previous day and night. And so many others replied to my posts. No, the thread was not quiet Luca, you were. Stop giving excuses. Just come out with it, you're scum.
first off, I didn't vote because like I said I wasn't sure on his alignment, plus even if I did vote it wouldn't have saved him considering everyone ran him over w/ the bandwagon, and a #NOVOTE would've done literally nothing. the only thing that would've saved him was a case protecting him, or he himself speaking up, and I read him as null then so I wouldn't have made a case just to save him at that time.
second, eshpas's lynch was from a bandwagon, but he got the bandwagon pushed really hard on him because he posted some really sketchy things just to get the game going.... someone else called it the esphas effect I believe. there's ways to get the game going.... and then there's the esphas effect aka what he did. that's why I said that. and like I said, all of the lynches so far are from bandwagons, no one is defending theirself and no one is defending others. plus being inactive isn't making finding scum any easier.
You kept repeating the same thing over and over and over. It's obvious you're trying to use this 'Esphas Effect' to justify yourself for not voting. Why didn't
you defend him? Why didn't you get online to try and push a lynch on your scum leans - Rosetti/Qwerty? That's because you didn't care. You already knew he was town and his lynch was to your favour.
Also Luca, even if you flipped town after all, I'm still pretty sure that you feel superior to the rest of us noobs.
Shiida- 3rd party. I believed her claim from the beginning of the game because it's kind of her thing to claim early. She could be helpful to town.
The fear of making incorrect reads makes me feel really anxious but there are still 2 scums left and these two are my biggest suspects.
