They didnt give him that in the safeclaim
-
Happy Earth Week! TBT is hosting a series of nature-based mini-events through April 28th. Breed flower hybrids by organizing your collectible lineup, enter our nature photography contest, purchase historically dated scenery collectibles, and earn bells around the site! Read more in the Earth Week and photography contest threads.
Mafia TBT Mafia: Game of Thrones - A Crown for a King - GAME OVER
- Thread starter Minties
- Start date
They didnt give him that in the safeclaim
JellofishXD
Senior Member
I knew he was scum because I posted that after he was lynched? I'm not defending Daniel AT ALL I have no idea why you got that impression.
- - - Post Merge - - -
How contradicting is this from your latest post. "As Jellyfish said, dissecting Danny's reads and 'useful' posts is gonna be important" this was the same post I made that you were suspicious of.
I didn't push Sataric though? I mean I don't see how possibly explain why Kit may have died is me seeking forgiveness but okay?
And I know I've been skirting by the last few days and posting a lot of excuses and I am really sorry about that. Honestly I should have let Sataric lynch me previous day because I'm just getting more and more distracted to the point where I'm having a hard time focusing on the game. A mixture of sickness from something that's been ailing me for the last couple weeks and depression is just hitting me really hard right now and when I come on I really don't feel like doing a whole lot gamewise except keep up and contribute minor opinions that snowball into major threads. Hopefully once I cool down in a bit I'll post some basic reads along with why I feel that way but I'm truly sorry.
Did you even read my two large posts from Day Two? If you did and still think what you said here is true then that is just insulting. I'm going back to bed.
Do you want to know my role?
no fancy post, no quotes, nothing in depth. i dont have the energy for that right now. my reads based off everything i've skimmed. yes to those lurking/obs they're ****. not going to defend them but im pretty sure you all want to know who i think is scum we/
Oath2order - Slow start to really contribute, took until Call Me Daniel's lynch to really dig in and post something. Generally receiving town based feels from his posts.
Ness - Originally felt town vibes, generally spammy. doesnt appear to be a weak link in scum tema. probable good king candidate.
panda - unsure. been quiet, blames parties. tunneled ness day 1 and then asked for llamas to be lynched instead. ???
avidear - new. lurks a bit. haven't reeally notuced much contribution. ???
sataric - comes off as town. possible sk, not certain. seems to have town interest at heart
- luca idk
tina - really undecided. haven't felt any vibes, blames it on rl situation. understandable. ??
trundle i dont trust trundle. i dont like that claim. it feels odd.
blu rose not sure. there was a post i skimmed a few pages back, will reread and update from there. ???
trojan i dont think i need to explain how much i really dont feel like trojan is town. pretty sure he's bad scum or just bad in general
dolby unlucky? idk constant radio silence because no internet. or supposed no internet. posts enough to skate by modkill.
meow idk. quiet. iirc they didnt post much day two. could be wrong. probable scum.
jello is skating by. despite better judgment i feel they're town despite the silence. null town.
Oath2order - Slow start to really contribute, took until Call Me Daniel's lynch to really dig in and post something. Generally receiving town based feels from his posts.
Ness - Originally felt town vibes, generally spammy. doesnt appear to be a weak link in scum tema. probable good king candidate.
panda - unsure. been quiet, blames parties. tunneled ness day 1 and then asked for llamas to be lynched instead. ???
avidear - new. lurks a bit. haven't reeally notuced much contribution. ???
sataric - comes off as town. possible sk, not certain. seems to have town interest at heart
- luca idk
tina - really undecided. haven't felt any vibes, blames it on rl situation. understandable. ??
trundle i dont trust trundle. i dont like that claim. it feels odd.
blu rose not sure. there was a post i skimmed a few pages back, will reread and update from there. ???
trojan i dont think i need to explain how much i really dont feel like trojan is town. pretty sure he's bad scum or just bad in general
dolby unlucky? idk constant radio silence because no internet. or supposed no internet. posts enough to skate by modkill.
meow idk. quiet. iirc they didnt post much day two. could be wrong. probable scum.
jello is skating by. despite better judgment i feel they're town despite the silence. null town.
here are my thoughts:
its 1AM, this took a loooot longer than I thought it would to type out. oops
Just to make this clear: Kingmaker do NOT King Trundle, and guys stop townreading him. There are a lot of things in his claims that don't add up. I feel really strongly that he should be lynched.
- - - Post Merge - - -
If you choose to only analyze one section of my post and skim the rest, pls read the part about Trundle.
Kingmaker, pls choose either Sataric again, Oath, or Ness.
Sataric -100% not mafia, 90% town. lynched Daniel without asking the rest of Town, based on his behavior + intuition, didn?t want to lynch Tom due to Tom?s defenses. possible 3rd party/sk. I say this because he most definitely genuinely wants to kill scum, but that?s not to rule him out as a serial killer.
What is a bit strange to me is that he never made a case against Daniel. He didn?t give the chance for him to explain and defend himself. Sataric also was suspicious of me, and he made this clear. He questioned me a lot. since I?m a new player, I would assume that he would have been more inclined to question Daniel to give him a chance, and yolo vote me or Trojan instead of a more experienced player that potentially could?ve been town. after all, that was his reasoning against lynching Tom.
He seemed to be testing Tom right here.... this makes me want to think he?s town. but still, not enough to rule him out as 3rd party.
What is a bit strange to me is that he never made a case against Daniel. He didn?t give the chance for him to explain and defend himself. Sataric also was suspicious of me, and he made this clear. He questioned me a lot. since I?m a new player, I would assume that he would have been more inclined to question Daniel to give him a chance, and yolo vote me or Trojan instead of a more experienced player that potentially could?ve been town. after all, that was his reasoning against lynching Tom.
He seemed to be testing Tom right here.... this makes me want to think he?s town. but still, not enough to rule him out as 3rd party.
Ness:
Although sometimes he jumps to conclusions, for the most part you can tell he genuinely will form an argument before attacking someone. based on all his contributions, pretty sure he?s town. he was a bit upset when Daniel was lynched, because although he scumread Daniel he didn?t like the fact that Sataric lynched him without allowing Daniel to defend himself.
Lucanosa: almost 99% sure that he is town. N2 happened without Weeny, since he was a troll alt that was banned. Two mafia kills and a 3rd party role kill happened N2, so imo this clears him from being sk and most likely isn?t mafia. (unless The Godfather is the only one that PMs the host about kills, then my opinion of Lucanosa is neutral)
Although sometimes he jumps to conclusions, for the most part you can tell he genuinely will form an argument before attacking someone. based on all his contributions, pretty sure he?s town. he was a bit upset when Daniel was lynched, because although he scumread Daniel he didn?t like the fact that Sataric lynched him without allowing Daniel to defend himself.
Lucanosa: almost 99% sure that he is town. N2 happened without Weeny, since he was a troll alt that was banned. Two mafia kills and a 3rd party role kill happened N2, so imo this clears him from being sk and most likely isn?t mafia. (unless The Godfather is the only one that PMs the host about kills, then my opinion of Lucanosa is neutral)
Oath: genuinely contributing to this game, I want to clear him as town but there?s always the possibility. however with how much effort he put into his compilation & analysis post of Daniel + Ender, I?m very inclined to think he?s not mafia. the only thing that I didn?t like about his posts is that he?s a bit too neutral on a lot of people. I think if he was a bit more accusatory in his reads I would feel stronger about him.
Tom: tbh I don?t know. I don?t want to say I?m suspicious of him until I see what he has to say in the next 48 hours. I totally acknowledge the fact that if he was mafia of course he?s going to say whatever he thinks it takes, and that?s why I don?t feel strongly about him. But I also think that if he was mafia, he would have lynched Kit on D1. A lot of people were suspicious of her, but he blueread her. Of course, there?s the possibility that he blueread her and wanted to kill a townie as well to maximize kills.
Trojan
why do u have to ****post lmao
at first I thought he was town aligned, because this is similar to how he played in Forest Fire. at least this game you can tell that he is sorta trying by actually asking questions. I didn?t suspect him much until he contradicted himself by saying that he scumread Daniel, when he did the opposite.
Tina:
Quite hard to read her... Her reads are all very careful it seems. She also did push Daniel, and unlike Trundle she was very precise with her accusation. Yet I have a weird feeling about her. She goes through every single possible outcome that she can think of, for example with Endless & Trundle.
Well now that we know that Endless was town I want to see if she continues to push Trundle. If she doesn?t, I?m going to see that as kind of suspicious unless she has good reasoning why not. Cause I actually don?t follow the reasoning in that, at the time it was not impossible that Trundle is town, I don?t get why she ruled that out immediately.
Ironically, now that Karla's role PM was released & I looked more into Trundle, I find it almost impossible that he's town. Since she's accused both Daniel + Trundle, mostly based off good reasoning, it seems unlikely to me that she's mafia. I'm leaning towards town.
Tom: tbh I don?t know. I don?t want to say I?m suspicious of him until I see what he has to say in the next 48 hours. I totally acknowledge the fact that if he was mafia of course he?s going to say whatever he thinks it takes, and that?s why I don?t feel strongly about him. But I also think that if he was mafia, he would have lynched Kit on D1. A lot of people were suspicious of her, but he blueread her. Of course, there?s the possibility that he blueread her and wanted to kill a townie as well to maximize kills.
Trojan
why do u have to ****post lmao
at first I thought he was town aligned, because this is similar to how he played in Forest Fire. at least this game you can tell that he is sorta trying by actually asking questions. I didn?t suspect him much until he contradicted himself by saying that he scumread Daniel, when he did the opposite.
Tina:
Quite hard to read her... Her reads are all very careful it seems. She also did push Daniel, and unlike Trundle she was very precise with her accusation. Yet I have a weird feeling about her. She goes through every single possible outcome that she can think of, for example with Endless & Trundle.
Well now that we know that Endless was town I want to see if she continues to push Trundle. If she doesn?t, I?m going to see that as kind of suspicious unless she has good reasoning why not. Cause I actually don?t follow the reasoning in that, at the time it was not impossible that Trundle is town, I don?t get why she ruled that out immediately.
Ironically, now that Karla's role PM was released & I looked more into Trundle, I find it almost impossible that he's town. Since she's accused both Daniel + Trundle, mostly based off good reasoning, it seems unlikely to me that she's mafia. I'm leaning towards town.
Trundle -
I was neutral on Trundle for awhile. what originally threw me off about Trundle is that he pushed Daniel the most out of everyone. It seemed pretty unlikely that he?s scum because not too much suspicion was on Daniel for that days lynch apart from Sataric and Tina.... but then I remembered Daniel was almost lynched on D1. I think it?s very likely that Trundle bussed Daniel since many eyes were already on Daniel and then claimed Vig to try to prove his alignment.
Bold move. And now everyone seems convinced he?s town and wants to vote him as King. But a few things don?t add up. We know mafia has at least 3 members right now for their KP to be 2. It doesn?t seem likely that there?s a 4th, since 6 mafia/23 players seems pretty unfair.
So far there?s been 3 blue roles revealed. It?s safe to assume a doctor exists, along with Kingmaker. A hero seems very likely, as it was in Tom?s Kingmaker game as well; but even if Hero doesn?t exist there could be a Veteran as Karla and others mentioned. I think it?s safe to assume that there?s 6 blue roles.
But with Trundle?s claim... and Karla definitely being a Vig, that means if he?s telling the truth there are 7 blue roles. We are 100% sure that there's a SK role of some sort. meaning that there are more power roles than Townies???
This just doesn?t seem likely to me and if it?s the case, this game is biased. AND, if he was Vig.... There?s no way you?re just going to use your shot N1 like that.
Just look at what he said in his defense:
The first sentence is a giant red flag. In Karla?s role PM, it clearly says that if your shot misses, it will not be refunded. There?s no way that if there are 2 Vigs, that Minties would include that part in one but not the other. The correct answer to this question would have been no. if he was really Vig, he would have known that.
His claims for shooting Endless are just plain weak, so you had a feeling and therefor thought it was best to shoot him before even forming an argument with him?? No. Endless claimed that he was saved and so you claimed Vig to convince everyone of your alignment. And then you bussed Daniel to make you seem even more Town.
Really funny that you didn?t want to even ARGUE on basic accusations on D1 but then you claim that killing someone N1 that you didn?t even argue with is reasonable.
It is possible he?s sk. but if he was sk he would be more in the background. I wanted to townread him too, until I actually read back on all his posts. guys pls don't just townread him, there's no way he's Vig. & Kingmaker whatever you do DO NOT King Trundle.
Blu Rose:
first thing that?s offputting: he hasn?t really pushed anyone all game.
2nd: his behavior the entire end of D1
He says immediately that he's not in support of a Tom lynch, but every other sentence in his post says that he's not against it either. He didn?t feel the need to even mention who he's suspicious of.
These two posts are just all over the place.... First quote basically says that Daniel wouldn?t have the ability to fake claim... Second says that ?yes, ik his team could?ve fabricated that, but if he was mafia then he?d just give up and stop revealing info?
if I was mafia I certainly wouldn?t, especially if I had nothing to lose. Not believing that Daniel could have came up with the Hero claim himself, is just the weakest reason to believe Daniel. I would have believed him more if he would have said something along the lines of "well there is still the possibility he's town.." like everyone else.
and that bolded part..like..why would you even say this as town. in the event Daniel flips red, wouldn?t you want him to give us info? even if he is just trying to confuse us, it?s better than nothing.
Panda
She was a lot more questioning and interrogating in the last game I played with her. The only person she?s really pushed is Ness. She asked when Night is over twice, when Dolby answered her right after he asked. She needs to contribute more and stop focusing on only one person, it seems like she?s barely paying attention to what?s going on. Even just right now, she asked Oath if he questioned aVidear?s alignment like two pages after he wrote a long post including why he thinks we should lynch aVidear. and she is still pushing Ness without presenting an actual case, and asking to be King?d like what even
Dolby: impossible to read since he has only made 1 contributing post. while I do agree with some of his points, if he doesn?t start being active, he needs to be lynched.
Jello: barely even posts, and when they do, it?s almost entirely contradicting. mentioned that we shouldn?t let aVidear ?sail through the game? but is literally doing the same thing. tbh I wish Karla would have shot him instead of meg. but I don?t think he?s worth lynching today.
aVidear: posted in the beginning and now we barely have anything. the only argument he made was on Trojan and wasn?t based on much. To me, he is not worth killing right now. He could be mafia, but imo it?s way more likely that he just doesn?t know how to play given that this is his first game.
I was neutral on Trundle for awhile. what originally threw me off about Trundle is that he pushed Daniel the most out of everyone. It seemed pretty unlikely that he?s scum because not too much suspicion was on Daniel for that days lynch apart from Sataric and Tina.... but then I remembered Daniel was almost lynched on D1. I think it?s very likely that Trundle bussed Daniel since many eyes were already on Daniel and then claimed Vig to try to prove his alignment.
Bold move. And now everyone seems convinced he?s town and wants to vote him as King. But a few things don?t add up. We know mafia has at least 3 members right now for their KP to be 2. It doesn?t seem likely that there?s a 4th, since 6 mafia/23 players seems pretty unfair.
So far there?s been 3 blue roles revealed. It?s safe to assume a doctor exists, along with Kingmaker. A hero seems very likely, as it was in Tom?s Kingmaker game as well; but even if Hero doesn?t exist there could be a Veteran as Karla and others mentioned. I think it?s safe to assume that there?s 6 blue roles.
But with Trundle?s claim... and Karla definitely being a Vig, that means if he?s telling the truth there are 7 blue roles. We are 100% sure that there's a SK role of some sort. meaning that there are more power roles than Townies???
This just doesn?t seem likely to me and if it?s the case, this game is biased. AND, if he was Vig.... There?s no way you?re just going to use your shot N1 like that.
Just look at what he said in his defense:
The first sentence is a giant red flag. In Karla?s role PM, it clearly says that if your shot misses, it will not be refunded. There?s no way that if there are 2 Vigs, that Minties would include that part in one but not the other. The correct answer to this question would have been no. if he was really Vig, he would have known that.
His claims for shooting Endless are just plain weak, so you had a feeling and therefor thought it was best to shoot him before even forming an argument with him?? No. Endless claimed that he was saved and so you claimed Vig to convince everyone of your alignment. And then you bussed Daniel to make you seem even more Town.
Really funny that you didn?t want to even ARGUE on basic accusations on D1 but then you claim that killing someone N1 that you didn?t even argue with is reasonable.
It is possible he?s sk. but if he was sk he would be more in the background. I wanted to townread him too, until I actually read back on all his posts. guys pls don't just townread him, there's no way he's Vig. & Kingmaker whatever you do DO NOT King Trundle.
Blu Rose:
first thing that?s offputting: he hasn?t really pushed anyone all game.
2nd: his behavior the entire end of D1
He says immediately that he's not in support of a Tom lynch, but every other sentence in his post says that he's not against it either. He didn?t feel the need to even mention who he's suspicious of.
These two posts are just all over the place.... First quote basically says that Daniel wouldn?t have the ability to fake claim... Second says that ?yes, ik his team could?ve fabricated that, but if he was mafia then he?d just give up and stop revealing info?
if I was mafia I certainly wouldn?t, especially if I had nothing to lose. Not believing that Daniel could have came up with the Hero claim himself, is just the weakest reason to believe Daniel. I would have believed him more if he would have said something along the lines of "well there is still the possibility he's town.." like everyone else.
and that bolded part..like..why would you even say this as town. in the event Daniel flips red, wouldn?t you want him to give us info? even if he is just trying to confuse us, it?s better than nothing.
Panda
She was a lot more questioning and interrogating in the last game I played with her. The only person she?s really pushed is Ness. She asked when Night is over twice, when Dolby answered her right after he asked. She needs to contribute more and stop focusing on only one person, it seems like she?s barely paying attention to what?s going on. Even just right now, she asked Oath if he questioned aVidear?s alignment like two pages after he wrote a long post including why he thinks we should lynch aVidear. and she is still pushing Ness without presenting an actual case, and asking to be King?d like what even
Dolby: impossible to read since he has only made 1 contributing post. while I do agree with some of his points, if he doesn?t start being active, he needs to be lynched.
Jello: barely even posts, and when they do, it?s almost entirely contradicting. mentioned that we shouldn?t let aVidear ?sail through the game? but is literally doing the same thing. tbh I wish Karla would have shot him instead of meg. but I don?t think he?s worth lynching today.
aVidear: posted in the beginning and now we barely have anything. the only argument he made was on Trojan and wasn?t based on much. To me, he is not worth killing right now. He could be mafia, but imo it?s way more likely that he just doesn?t know how to play given that this is his first game.
its 1AM, this took a loooot longer than I thought it would to type out. oops
Just to make this clear: Kingmaker do NOT King Trundle, and guys stop townreading him. There are a lot of things in his claims that don't add up. I feel really strongly that he should be lynched.
- - - Post Merge - - -
If you choose to only analyze one section of my post and skim the rest, pls read the part about Trundle.
Kingmaker, pls choose either Sataric again, Oath, or Ness.
Ok so tom I get the feeling from that post you're drunk.
Meow I really don't like your read on trundle, there is a difference between a base and an full blown attack. I'm not sure if this is just a bad read or something else. I'll be watching your posts from now on.
Meow I really don't like your read on trundle, there is a difference between a base and an full blown attack. I'm not sure if this is just a bad read or something else. I'll be watching your posts from now on.
JellofishXD
Senior Member
@ Karla - I knew something was not right about your roleclaim. Sad to see you die. Shame about that wasted kill on Meg, though depending on how you see it, at least now we don't have to be suspicious of her being scum. But we desperatly need to protect the townies we have left now. We have lost far too many.
I have to agree. After seeing the names of the characters that just died on Night 2, they are all very Stark-related like you said, and most if not all also have strong ties to the town of Winterfell where as the Lannisters and their allies (See EnderWiggin's role 'The Mountain') are tied to Casterly Rock or Kings Landing. Loras Tyrell is most prominently associated with Highgarden.
This post makes no sense, Ness. We know the Kingmaker, at the very least, is alive - And that should be a blue role. Furthermore, I hope we have a doctor of some kind if nothing else. But at this stage in the game, with so many kills still occurring, we HAVE to get that Mafia KP down or remove the SK or whatever killing role a third-party might have or else we'll run out of both townies and blues very soon.
Personally, I feel like you'd make a better king than Oath but I am glad I was selected once more. Hopefully I can keep myself from making any mistakes. I will try to use the intent to hammer idea today but might select more than one person at the same time if we're running low on time.
@ Everyone - I am glad that many have posted their suspicions already. With so many town people dying last night, we now have no room to sit back and idly try to weed out the low-contributing players or annoying spam-posters. We need to reduce the KP or get rid of that killing third-party as soon as possible - Preferably with today's lynch. It feels like many of the people that I have gotten decent town-reads upon find similar targets suspicious. This could potentially be very good. But it also means that if you are TOWN and you are on many people's suspicions list, you better prove your worth ASAP or you could be the one dying next and essentially screwing up the entire game by being stupidly scummy despite your town-tag. Please do not let this happen. Thanks.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also, I won't be home tomorrow night my time which is when the day will end as it is my fathers birthday, so we have about 24 hours before I submit my vote at most.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also - Night 1 we had 3 deaths and 1 save. (With Trundle using his shot on the saved target.)
Night 2 we had 4 deaths and 0 saves. (With Karla using his shot to account for one of the kills.)
Despite 2 Mafias being killed off, kills per night seems to be the same..
I have to agree. After seeing the names of the characters that just died on Night 2, they are all very Stark-related like you said, and most if not all also have strong ties to the town of Winterfell where as the Lannisters and their allies (See EnderWiggin's role 'The Mountain') are tied to Casterly Rock or Kings Landing. Loras Tyrell is most prominently associated with Highgarden.
This post makes no sense, Ness. We know the Kingmaker, at the very least, is alive - And that should be a blue role. Furthermore, I hope we have a doctor of some kind if nothing else. But at this stage in the game, with so many kills still occurring, we HAVE to get that Mafia KP down or remove the SK or whatever killing role a third-party might have or else we'll run out of both townies and blues very soon.
Personally, I feel like you'd make a better king than Oath but I am glad I was selected once more. Hopefully I can keep myself from making any mistakes. I will try to use the intent to hammer idea today but might select more than one person at the same time if we're running low on time.
@ Everyone - I am glad that many have posted their suspicions already. With so many town people dying last night, we now have no room to sit back and idly try to weed out the low-contributing players or annoying spam-posters. We need to reduce the KP or get rid of that killing third-party as soon as possible - Preferably with today's lynch. It feels like many of the people that I have gotten decent town-reads upon find similar targets suspicious. This could potentially be very good. But it also means that if you are TOWN and you are on many people's suspicions list, you better prove your worth ASAP or you could be the one dying next and essentially screwing up the entire game by being stupidly scummy despite your town-tag. Please do not let this happen. Thanks.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also, I won't be home tomorrow night my time which is when the day will end as it is my fathers birthday, so we have about 24 hours before I submit my vote at most.
- - - Post Merge - - -
Also - Night 1 we had 3 deaths and 1 save. (With Trundle using his shot on the saved target.)
Night 2 we had 4 deaths and 0 saves. (With Karla using his shot to account for one of the kills.)
Despite 2 Mafias being killed off, kills per night seems to be the same..
idek oath i'm so sorry
First thing: True, true.
Second thing: I wasn't against a Tom lynch and still am not. I'm also not for a Tom lynch and wasn't suspicious of anyone due to the first thing you mentioned.
Third thing:
Fair enough. Please explain how these are "all over the place," I can't seem to locate it myself.m3ow_ said:
u wot m8m3ow_ said:
Okay, look. The claim and gambit that CMD did are honestly way above anything that has happened post-hammer in TBT Mafia. Seeing as TBT Mafia is literally my only experience of Mafia on the Internet, it makes sense for me to think it unexpected, as many people in the past claim roles after the hammer that--you'll never guess--are their legitimate roles. This LITERALLY makes the expected outcome a claim of his role. My reason for believing Daniel was not essentially that I didn't believe in his apparent ability--albeit I'll admit to only posting that in the thread--, more of an "in my experience" thing. Questions?
Whether or not I want him to give us info is trivial: My desires didn't influence CMD's actions. I would want him to give us more info, yes. Would he want to give us more info? No. So, why would he continue to talk as Mafia post hammer (unless if he were attempting to get more info himself, which apparently happens ALL THE TIME and I'm the only one unaware of it)?m3ow_ said:
oath2order
#Porygon2024
So then sat who are you lookin at
Nobody should consider themselves safe. In a sense, I suppose I am looking at everyone. That's the best way to proceed, don't you think? I will carefully go through people's post history once again in the end but for now what worries me the most is that I have no idea who the kingmaker is and it'd be a damn tragedy to have them executed after they put their faith in me twice.
I suppose top scum-read as of this very moment - Though this is very likely subject to change - Is: Trojan, Panda, Jellofish, Blu Rose, aVidear and Tina. I am still very displeased with your list of whom to lynch for the previous day, Oath, so I am looking at you too. Tom as well. And Dolby. Did I miss anyone?
The sheer amount of people that's got a bad vibe from Blu Rose alone is really causing me to consider them as my primary target as of right now, but at the same time if a name is tossed around a lot that means that potentially a few scummies have mentioned them too.
I feel like Karla's last will made some very solid points regarding aVidear and then he claims common Townie when not put under significant pressure afterwards.
Making a role-claim out of the blue when not even put under any kind of real pressure made him look even scummier than he did before, but I am waiting for him to spit out his role name since it was already requested and his role is out in the open either way.
Tom playing the "I'm so disinterested, maybe you should just lynch me.." is sad to me in so many ways because even though I understand he's going through some awful scenarios in real life, Tina (who mentioned being in the same position) ended up making some really solid posts nonetheless, and in generally I just feel that such statements is kind of rude towards Minties who is working her butt off to make the game enjoyable for everyone. Tom, being one of the best players in Mafia overall in my opinion, and a really polite guy, should know better than to be so blatantly "meh!" about the whole game. Still, I hope he will feel better soon.
oath2order
#Porygon2024
I may have had bad candidates at day but then my masterpost so.
Did anyone go back to see who Ender/Daniel avoided talking about
Still waiting on avidear's role name
Did anyone go back to see who Ender/Daniel avoided talking about
Still waiting on avidear's role name
Well yeah, but I mean think about it: We've lost a total of 3 Blue's in the first few nights. Given how low Blue roles tend to be in count I'm pretty certain we're starting to run out of blues. With Trundles claim and Kingmaker on our hands, i'm pretty sure the most we can suspect would be anything but 3-4 blue roles.
I believe the that the inclusion of so many blue roles is because of the strength of the mafia team + third party role. Minties may have balanced the game by adding strength to town rather than removing power from the mafia team.
That is a possibility. Let me ask you - If you were king today, who would you have lynched?
From activity and behaviour, it would be between Tom and Trojan. I believe right after N1 ended there were some decent argument on Tom that explained why he hasn't been furiously attacking me this game. I think he falls under the same umbrella as Daniel. Trojan seems to be passing the game by like all his other games and I have reason to believe his town and mafia behaviour would be no different.
Similar threads
