Can't really think of anything right now besides a recap. Seven of us left and this is where we stand:
oath2order:
- Claimed Judge in the main thread. Anonymous vote appeared during the Superpenguin lynch yesterday as he indicated.
- Has been talkative and active. Headed the Superpenguin lynch alongside Alice and Gandalf.
- Similar role to the The Hammerer given to Jer in Pleasure Cruise mafia. Possible Godfather if scum did receive blue roles.
Gandalf
- Already claimed as the third Emily Brent in the thread.
- May have started the Superpenguin lynch and ****ed everything up.
- Probably going to get lynched today.
Cory
- Claimed Veteran in the main thread. Wanted everyone to roleclaim to him to identify counter claims and scum.
- Has not posted in the main thread since the start of day 4.
- Took part in the Superpenguin lynch being the last to vote him and without any further explanation.
- Also possible Godfather.
MrKisstoefur
- Active and talkative.
- Contributed to day 4 lynch by defending himself and superpenguin.
- Inspected by Alice on night 3 and returned as Vera Claythorne
PurplPanda
- Just replaced CookingOkasan. Not enough time to give much input.
- Claimed to be the third Thomas Rogers in the main thread
- Did not vote day 4.
Faloreena
- Not a huge amount of input.
- Claimed Tony Marston in the thread.
- Bandwagon'd Superpenguin with the rest without further explanation.
Nikkinikki
- Few ideas here and there, no huge revelations (minus Jer being scum, but remember Mr Owen was just made up by one of the killers/guests).
- Claimed Ethel Rogers in the thread.
- Did not vote day 4.
No real reason to go into the voting thread as it seems everyone has just been following the same Townie miss lynch's each day. We are all basically bandwagoning people, usually from a different persons evidence each day, and screwing up. Note that the godfather points are just there as the mafia might have been balanced with a blue role considering they could have been a little underpowered given their small starting numbers.
On roles, we currently have:
- Two dead Thomas Rogers and one living claim
- Two dead Emily Brent's and one living claim
- One dead Vera Claythorne and one confirmed inspection.
- One dead Tony Marston and one living claim.
- One dead Ethel Rogers and one living claim.
- Two dead Blue's - one doctor and one detective.
- Two living Blue claims - one veteran and one judge.
That makes 16.
We know that there is a judge in play from the votes, and as said before the current claims show there may not be a vigilante. We don't have any confirmation on Cory being a veteran besides his own word and he doesn't even seem to be trying anymore. I'm also not as suspicious of MrKisstoefur now considering the way he acted during the Superpenguin lynch. He easily could have stayed to the side and let it all play out, only defending himself, but he did speak up for both which is something I don't think scum would have done.
NikkiNikki and Feloreena are about the same in my books now. They aren't doing anything huge or dangerous so that could mean they are hiding a killer role and just laying low. Feloreena remember was part of the reason Mewmewmew was lynched - the conflicting Townie roles - and again that isn't how I would have expected scum to react in the situation. Speaking out against it to get Mew lynched would have just put them under too much suspicion to be worth the single lynch at the very start of the game. NikkiNikki on the other hand has just voted and made small talk up until now. I don't really have anything on them.
Purplpanda is quiet, and they did just join the game, but I also want to hear what they might be thinking. On oath2order I have no read. He was keen on getting Superpenguin lynched but I mean all the reasons were definitely there for it. His role does seem to be the most appropriate one to make scum though and that's really all i can bring up against him, though this also applies to Cory so yeah I give up. Isn't even something about his playstyle or actions, just a random thought. I would say he is pretty much confirmed to be the judge, but we still won't be able to find out his allegiance.
So yeah that leaves me here for you all to decide on.. Other than that,
Cory or
NikkiNikki are who I would consider for lynch today. Cory is the bigger risk though as two night lives will extend the guests lifespan if he really is town aligned, but at this stage he is the last person scum are going to target so he will probably be one of the remaining guests if scum make it to their winning conditions, so really not too much to lose.
Alice's death is difficult to analyse. She was pretty much revealed in the thread as a detective so I guess it wasn't too difficult for the killers to make the decision. She sent this to me after mew's lynch:
Alice said:
We were questioning her because we knew she came up as Tony. We know the DT, and if she was claiming DT then she was obviously scum.
She was investigated night 1.
Alice said:
Also, I meant night 0. The plan is for Felo to investigated tonight. So we'll see in the morning.
That was the first time Alice contacted me by pm or IRC and I was pretty much guessing afterwards that she was the detective. If anyone is still in serious doubt over my allegiance, just consider why I would have left her alive for so long knowing all this. Would you do that if you were scum? No. I would have killed her that night.
This is all last resort though, anyone got some better reads to add in? It's been such a waffley post because this doesn't seem to be like a normal mafia game... there are no real conflicts in the thread or pm's that I can get a read off..
