I know you haven't been on for about two days, but on the off chance you see this soon, here is your chance to get Papi: http://www.belltreeforums.com/showthread.php?199099-Papi-the-lazy-horse&p=3339564#post3339564
This will be cross posted at several other forums, but since he's not often sought out as a villager you have a good chance if you're on soon.
This will be cross posted at several other forums, but since he's not often sought out as a villager you have a good chance if you're on soon.